• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • The Newspaper
  • Our Team
  • PDF Books
  • Archive
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us

Scena Criminis

L'Informazione al servizio della Legalità

  • EnglishEnglish
    • ItalianoItaliano
    • EnglishEnglish
    • EspañolEspañol
  • News & History
    • History of Crime
    • Criminal Words
    • Gender Violence
    • News
    • Organized Crime
  • Quotes, Interviews, Videos
    • Interviews
    • Quotes
    • Videos
  • Crime & Art
    • Recommended Books
    • Criminal Portraits
    • The Eye that Kills: Cinema and Crime
    • Violent Art
  • Criminal Biographies
    • Caserta: Crimes from the Past
    • Criminal Biographies
    • Most Wanted
    • Mysteries and Unsolved Crimes
    • Serial Killer
    • Snapshots from a Crime
  • Forensic Sciences
    • Criminalistics
      • Ballistics: Rifles and Guns
    • Criminology
      • Psychology
      • Sociology
    • Law
    • Nonverbal Communication
You are here: Home / Forensic Sciences / The load of Lying: testing for Truth

The load of Lying: testing for Truth

22 March 2015 da admin Leave a Comment

0Shares

We may think we know the telltale signs of lying, be it shifty eyes or nervous fidgeting. Professional interrogators look for such tells, too, assuming a suspect’s nervousness betrays his guilt. But interrogation can rattle even the innocent, so nervousness alone cannot distinguish liars from truth-tellers.

Scientists looking for better ways to detect lies have found a promising one: increasing suspects’ “cognitive load.” For a host of reasons, their theory goes, lying is more mentally taxing than telling the truth. Per­forming an extra task while lying or telling the truth should therefore affect the liars more.

To test this idea, deception researchers led by psychologist Aldert Vrij of the University of Portsmouth in England asked one group to lie con­vincingly and another group to tell the truth about a staged theft scenario that only the truth-tellers had experi­enced. A second pair of groups had to do the same but with a crucial twist: both the liars and the truth-tellers had to maintain eye contact while telling their stories.

Later, as researchers watched videotapes of the suspects’ accounts, they tallied verbal signs of cognitive load (such as fewer spatial details in the suspects’ stories) and nonverbal ones (such as fewer eyeblinks). The eyeblinks are particularly interesting because whereas rapid blinking suggests nervousness, fewer blinks are a sign of cognitive load, Vrij explains—and contrary to what police are taught, liars tend to blink less. Although the effect was subtle, the instruction to maintain eye contact did magnify the differences between the truth-tellers and the liars.

So do these differences actually make it easier for others to distinguish liars from truth-tellers? They do—but although students watching the videos had an easier time spotting a liar in the eye-contact condition, their accuracy rates were still poor. Any group differences between liars and truth-tellers were dwarfed by differences be­tween individual participants. (For example, some people blink far less than others whether or not they are lying—and some are simply better able to carry a higher cognitive load.)

All this makes it hard to put the study’s findings into practice—especially out in the field, where the people most likely to lie are those who are good at lying. “In the real world, there’s no Pinocchio-like cue that distinguishes liars from truth-tellers,” says study co-author Ronald Fisher of Florida International University. Magnifying subtle differences may be the next best thing.

Source: scientificamerican.com

Related posts:

The Invasive Reach of the CyberBully: The Virtual Stalker of the Younger Generation
I Do but I Don't Have To: Marital Rape
Scientists find clue to why Mitochondrial DNA comes only from Mom
Breakthrough Technology uncovers Fingerprints on ATM Bills and Receipts
0Shares

Filed Under: Forensic Sciences, Psychology

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Make a donation to support our activities

Stay updated in real time

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Loading

Follow us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Safe and prudent use of Internet

Categorie Articoli

Last Articles

Info

  • Business Contacts
  • Disclaimer

Tags

America american most wanted art artist Chicago crime crimen crime scene criminal Criminalistics criminology disorder Dna fbi fingerprints forensics forensic science homicide killer law most wanted Murder Nonverbal Communication oil on canvas painting paintings police prison psicólogia psychology psychology today research reward scena criminis science sciencedaily serial killer sex offender terrorism terrorist treatment US USA violence violent art

Footer

Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy

Scene Criminis aims to bring together – around a “round table” – experts, students and simple onlookers, who want to confront, update and find new stimuli.

The largest Italian Community on Forensic Sciences that collects news, studies, curiosities and contributions on Criminology, Criminalistics, Crime Report and Law.

Scena Criminis is also a Non-profit Association, active throughout the province of Caserta (Italy), which has 3 fundamental purposes: Defense of Legality, Fight against all forms of Violence, Education to Gender Differences.

Follow us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Instagram

scenacriminis

La faccia dell'avvocato parla da sola... 🤣🤣🤣

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
L'#allenamento è fondamentale 🤦‍♂️ 👉 L'#allenamento è fondamentale 🤦‍♂️

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
Alto livello... 🤦‍♂️ 👉 scenacriminis. Alto livello... 🤦‍♂️

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
Felicia Impastato ❤️

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
#love ❤️ 👉 scenacriminis.com 👈 #love ❤️

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
Ah, l'amore! 👀 #bodyofevidence 👉 scenacrim Ah, l'amore! 👀

#bodyofevidence

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
I mercatini riservano sempre grandi emozioni 😍 I mercatini riservano sempre grandi emozioni 😍

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
Antico kit forense 🕵‍♂️💀🖤 👉 sce Antico kit forense 🕵‍♂️💀🖤

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
#empathy 🤗 👉 scenacriminis.com 👈 #empathy 🤗

👉 scenacriminis.com 👈
Carica altro… Segui su Instagram

Copyright Scena Criminis Testata giornalistica registrata presso il Tribunale di Santa Maria Capua Vetere (CE) n. 849 del 26/04/2016 © 2022 ·

Direttore Responsabile: Gianfrancesco Coppo

Created by BDM | Log in