• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • The Newspaper
  • Our Team
  • PDF Books
  • Archive
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us

Scena Criminis

L'Informazione al servizio della Legalità

  • EnglishEnglish
    • ItalianoItaliano
    • EnglishEnglish
    • EspañolEspañol
  • News & History
    • History of Crime
    • Criminal Words
    • Gender Violence
    • News
    • Organized Crime
  • Quotes, Interviews, Videos
    • Interviews
    • Quotes
    • Videos
  • Crime & Art
    • Recommended Books
    • Criminal Portraits
    • The Eye that Kills: Cinema and Crime
    • Violent Art
  • Criminal Biographies
    • Caserta: Crimes from the Past
    • Criminal Biographies
    • Most Wanted
    • Mysteries and Unsolved Crimes
    • Serial Killer
    • Snapshots from a Crime
  • Forensic Sciences
    • Criminalistics
      • Ballistics: Rifles and Guns
    • Criminology
      • Psychology
      • Sociology
    • Law
    • Nonverbal Communication
You are here: Home / Forensic Sciences / Are Religious and Political Extremists crazy?

Are Religious and Political Extremists crazy?

25 October 2014 da admin Leave a Comment

0Shares

Every time there is a terrorist act or a mass murder, reporters start calling with questions on thepsychiatric diagnosis of the perp. The default position seems to be that every religious extremist or political fanatic or mass murderer must be crazy. How else to account for their weird behavior?

Naming a diagnosis somehow satisfies a deep human need to explain what otherwise seems an unexplainable act. But names can only describe, they do not explain.

Our diagnostic system has chosen not to consider fanaticism a mental disorder. But confusion nonetheless arises because there is no clear boundary separating religious and political extremism from psychiatric illness. One man’s cherished belief is another man’s delusion.

Take a classic example that occurred at the birth of forensic psychiatry. In 1861, Charles Guiteau successfully assassinated President James Garfield- based on the belief that he was God’s messenger sent to the US to protect it from an evil administration. His trial created a sensation. More than a dozen expert witnesses divided down the middle on the question of his sanity. Guiteau’s own words expressed the issue best: ‘I would rather be hung as a man than acquitted as a fool.”

The same scenario of adversarial expert testimony, for and against mental illness, has played out over and over again in trials of political and religious extremists (eg, the Unabomber, Breivik, and some religious terrorists). Sincere fanatics detest the insanity defense because it invalidates their beliefs. They too would rather be punished as criminals.

Experts usually can’t agree whether a political or religious criminal has done bad or is simply mad. Their cancelling out suggests that the question is not really a medical decision, more a societal one. We must accept that there is inherent uncertainty in distinguishing the merely strange from the clinically insane. If we are to call Guiteau crazy for believing himself to be a messenger of God, how do we distinguish him from the many prophets and saints who have been so revered for making similar claims.

Jumping to a fake mental disorder diagnosis in everyone who is violent has another serious downside. It unfairly stigmatizes the mentally ill, most of whom are not violent. The public and the press must accept that political or religious violence is usually just political or religious, not very often the result of diagnosable mental illness.

This fits the wishes of most defendants. They would, like Guiteau, much prefer to be punished than treated – lest their message be muffled. I would agree with them. Unless there is clear evidence of classic, pre-existing mental disorder, I would withhold diagnosis and give them the dignity of whatever is the suitable punishment.

Source: PsychologyToday

Author: Allen Frances, M.D., chair of the DSM-IV Task Force and is currently professor emeritus at Duke

Related posts:

DNA Evidence: basics of identifying, gathering and transporting
Stalking Risk increases among College Students
Strategy Games and Serial Killers
20 Clues to Toxic Bosses
0Shares

Filed Under: Forensic Sciences, Psychology

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Make a donation to support our activities

Stay updated in real time

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Loading

Follow us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Safe and prudent use of Internet

Categorie Articoli

Last Articles

Info

  • Business Contacts
  • Disclaimer

Tags

America american most wanted art artist Chicago crime crimen crime scene criminal Criminalistics crimine criminology CSI disorder Dna fbi forensics forensic science homicide killer law most wanted Murder Nonverbal Communication oil on canvas painting police prison psicólogia psychology psychology today research reward scena criminis science serial killer sex sex offender terrorism terrorist united states US USA violence violent art

Footer

Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy

Scene Criminis aims to bring together – around a “round table” – experts, students and simple onlookers, who want to confront, update and find new stimuli.

The largest Italian Community on Forensic Sciences that collects news, studies, curiosities and contributions on Criminology, Criminalistics, Crime Report and Law.

Scena Criminis is also a Non-profit Association, active throughout the province of Caserta (Italy), which has 3 fundamental purposes: Defense of Legality, Fight against all forms of Violence, Education to Gender Differences.

Follow us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Instagram

scenacriminis

Gli è andata male... 👮‍♂️ Gli è andata male... 👮‍♂️
Seguimi ➡️ scenacriminis.com 💪 Seguimi ➡️ scenacriminis.com 💪
➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️ ➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️
➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️ ➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️
Falso allarme... 🤦‍♂️ ➡️ www.scenacr Falso allarme... 🤦‍♂️

➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️
Altro che Jackie Chan! 😆 Altro che Jackie Chan! 😆
➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️ ➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️
➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️ ➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️
➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️ ➡️ www.scenacriminis.com ⬅️
Carica altro… Segui su Instagram

Copyright Scena Criminis Testata giornalistica registrata presso il Tribunale di Santa Maria Capua Vetere (CE) n. 849 del 26/04/2016 © 2023 ·

Direttore Responsabile: Gianfrancesco Coppo

Created by BDM | Log in